
The performances lack polish and finesse, naturally. Much of the cd is more like an auditory documentary than anything else. For example, the opening track "Swordfishermen's Calls," are exactly that - two male voices, shouting melodically over a long distance. This isn't the happy accordian music you hear at the Olive Garden, to say the least. The variety of the music is striking, containg a capella, tarantela, lullabies, accordians, bagpipes and melodies of surprising complexity. The vocals are a bit rough, sometimes - the Italians like to sing loud, apparently, and some of the singers go flat when they do.
The liner notes are extensive and contain English translations. Highly recommended, if you're looking for something truly authentic, a historical document rather than professional renditions of old folk songs.
Thank God Alan Lomax took the time and had the interest in the 1950's - when the Americanization bug was at its worst throughout Italy and timeless traditions were laughed upon and surpressed - to record these folk songs and to one day remind Italy of their beyond rich musical heritage (that they are slowly getting back into).
The only gripe I have about this collection is that all the songs are from the provinces of Catanzaro and Reggio di Calabria, nothing from Cosenza. The only CD where songs from Cosenza appear on is the "sampler" CD ("Folk Music and Songs of Italy"). It's a shame more material wasn't recorded in Cosenza, or was chosen not to be included in this collection.
Besides that, this is a great CD that will familiarize the folk music novice and expert alike with the sounds of Calabria.
Definitely worth the money and the time to listen to.